Martin Freeman plays Bilbo Baggins / Photo courtesy of Warner Brothers Pictures
The third and final installment of Peter Jackson’s expansive (some might say bloated) adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit begins right where the previous movie (The Desolation of Smaug) left off, with the flying, gargantuan dragon, Smaug, attacking Laketown, incinerating the quaint village with blasts of fire. Afterward, the wrangling begins for the rich, golden booty left behind within Smaug’s cavernous lair. The contenders: Dwarves, who claim the treasure as their birthright; Men, left homeless from the devastation, with their allies, the Elves; and the monstrous Orcs (considered an enemy by all). The latter take on a more prominent role here than in the book. Meanwhile, the nimble hobbit hero, Bilbo Baggins, continues to safeguard a secret: in his pocket, he carries the magic ring, which turns its wearer invisible. Why is the dragon attacking the peaceful, defenseless villagers of Laketown? The answer lies in Jackson’s last installment. The miserly creature suspects humans of trespassing upon his mountain, when the culprit was, in fact, the sneaky hobbit, Bilbo (played by Martin Freeman, in a constant state of bewilderment), under the service of the Dwarves. Those coming in cold to the multiplex will be left fumbling in the dark. The trilogy topper doesn’t stand alone, so having read the book or seen the previous movies is a must. Otherwise, it would be too easy to lose track of all of the late arrivals to the climactic battle scene, and some sequences would be downright confusing. In tone and look, the conclusion seamlessly blends in with Jackson’s first two entries: the wide-eyed, declamatory acting; the clunky dialogue (“If this is love, I don’t want it. Why does it hurt so much?”); the stentorian score by composer Howard Shore; and the whirl-and-twirl swordfights among the tireless combatants. The nonstop 3-D special effects are rendered redundant, with falling debris, incoming spears, or Smaug’s tail repeatedly descending upon movier goers—talk about overkill. Seeing Battle in either 3-D or 3-D IMAX won’t necessarily enhance the viewing experience, either, considering that the latter, overly bright format washes out and flattens the color palette. As in the previous two films, the new movie has a tone separate from Tolkien’s. Where the author's is wry and genial (“It does not do to leave a live dragon out of your calculations, if you live near him”), Jackson’s stretched-out adaptation gives off a militaristic bombast. Additionally, what was cuddly on the page is creepy and menacing onscreen, best exemplified by the Orcs, ashen giants wearing skulls as codpieces. Whereas Tolkien resolves a confrontation within a few pages or even a single sentence, Jackson draws out the killings and mayhem, though the script covers only the last 65 pages of the book. The titular confrontation lasts about an hour long. In contrast, Tolkien wraps up the final combat in one succinct chapter. After 30 months on his action-packed journey with the Dwarves, the wary Bilbo just wants to go back home and retire to his armchair with his books and tea at four o’clock. Likewise, the viewer might prefer cozying up with Tolkien’s original instead. Directed by Peter Jackson 144 min. Rated PG-13 (heads roll)We are currently offering this content for free. Sign up now to activate your personal profile, where you can save articles for future viewing
Add Comment :-
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!
Susu.ro
If you haven't read The Hobbit and/or if you like the first two movies: I envy you of sorts... If someone had told me some years ago that I would consider walking out from a Tolkien movie opening night, I would have slapped them with a cod. Or a salmon. The Hobbit trilogy is crap. It's little more than a long list of invented battles and love stories to attract a widest possible audience, as well as loads of idiotic storyline to make the story slide into the Lord of the Rings movies as smooth as an Elven ass. I understand that some adaption is required from book to screen, but when dealing with a book more or less only surpassed by the Bible and the IKEA catalogue, one should tread carefully. Do yourself a favor. Read the book. Let your mind be the big screen.Posted : Jan 15, 2015 09:01
Mary
I enjoyed reading this review,since I do think (much as I have enjoyed Jackson's movies) he gets the tone of "The Hobbit" wrong. Still, I am eager to see this. Martin Freeman pretty much nails Bilbo, and Richard Armitage is an awesome Thorin. One quibble with your review. "Goblins" and "Orcs" are the same people. So the armies are: Men, Elves, Dwarves, Orcs/Goblins, and Eagles. The fifth army is the eagles. I will be mightily disappointed if they don't show up!Posted : Dec 17, 2014 12:08