Who's That Girl

Gr 8 Up—Thornburgh deftly balances snark and optimism in this thoroughly delightful novelization of the song "Hey There Delilah." Brainy and adorably awkward Nattie leads a fairly average life: she's an active member of the LGBT club and has a group of quirky friends, enchantingly eccentric parents, and a mountain of Latin homework. Normally, her biggest enterprise would be pulling off Operation Big Gay Dance Party. Yet when Nattie's unrequited crush Sebastian Delacroix becomes an indie rock sensation with his sultry hit "Natalie," life takes a turn for the crazy. Is Nattie Sebastian's muse? Nattie becomes the subject of much social media speculation amid a quasi-flirtation with Sebastian, which turns her world topsy-turvy. Thornburgh manages subtle social media commentary. Afternoons spent baking and translating Catullus with good friend Zach the Anarchist muddy the waters further with Sebastian. Whom does Nattie like? Who sincerely cares for her? Superficial character development, a fairly stereotypical entourage, and soon-to-be-dated cultural references keep this novel lighthearted, which is Thornburgh's aim. Furthermore, there are few surprises in the lead-up to a happy ending. However, teens will want to read every page.