Gr 9 Up—This novel covers seventh grade to sophomore year from the points of view of four characters: Lily, a math whiz who is obsessed with Simon; Noah, who is in love with Lily, even though he knows she is not interested in him except for the cigarettes and marijuana he supplies; Simon, a writer who drifts through most of his days; and, briefly, Suzanne, Simon's sister. All four are dealing with problems at home and surviving as best they can. To the outside world they seem an inseparable unit, but they know little to nothing about each other's lives. In spite of a few interesting aspects, the book is unlikely to capture readers' attention. None of the characters is particularly likable or sympathetic, or exhibits any emotional growth. The narration from different points of view is confusing, especially Lily's section, which goes back and forth in time. Few teens will have the patience to see the story to its unsatisfying conclusion.—Suanne Roush, Osceola High School, Seminole, FL
Lily, Noah, and Simon are a trio of friends with a roiling mix of hidden complications in their lives: abuse, divorce, a father with cancer. As the three take turns narrating, it becomes clear that their friendship also conceals a fundamental lack of connection among them. Brezenoff explores the characters' interactions honestly and head-on, without neat intersections or happy endings.
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!