Rachel's Secret

Gr 5–10—On April 6, 1903, the Russian city of Kishinev erupted in violence as a mob of Christians descended upon the Jews, slaughtering many and leaving hundreds wounded. The catalyst for the riot was the murder of a Christian boy, Mikhail Rybachenko. After his death, the local newspaper began publishing reports that Jews were responsible. Soon rumors ran rampant in the city, inciting hatred. In this novel based on that event, 14-year-old Rachel, a Jewish girl, witnesses the murder and knows that Mikhail's uncle killed him, but is too terrified to tell what she saw. Sergei, a Christian and friend of the victim, is attracted to her, and she eventually confesses her secret to him. He plans to tell his police-chief father, believing that he will take care of everything. However, his father dismisses his claims and does nothing to stop the resulting riots. Rachel and Sergei are left feeling haunted by their inability to do anything. This is a compelling story about an unfamiliar historical event, but there is very little character development. Rachel and Sergei do not spend enough time together to have formed the bond the author suggests. Conversations are stilted and plot twists are unrealistic. However, the novel holds its value as an informational story that historical-fiction fans will appreciate.—Wendy Scalfaro, G. Ray Bodley High School, Fulton, NY