K-Gr 3—Puns and droll humor pepper this story of lonely Mr. Prickles, a porcupine who becomes justifiably unfriendly after struggling unsuccessfully to befriend the other woodland creatures. ("He tried to join in their midnight picnicking, but it was pointless.") Bold cartoon illustrations full of clever details and dark, shadowy colors draw out the humor but also make the pain of loneliness and rejection resonate. When Mr. Prickles meets another porcupine, Miss Pointypants, she convinces him that spending so much time glaring at the other animals is boring. Pretty soon they're having too much fun together to care about the unkind remarks made about them. Kids who know something of social cruelties will find familiar scenes and a happy ending here.—Julie Roach, Cambridge Public Library, MA
Mr. Prickles, a porcupine, has good reason to be prickly: the other forest animals callously spurn his many friendly overtures. Sadly, the more Chipmunk, Raccoon, and Skunk shun Mr. Prickles, the more bitter and unfriendly he becomes. LaReau's well-paced, pointedly pun-filled text shines a sympathetic light on her lonely protagonist, while Magoon's playful illustrations bring out the best in the spiky hero.
Mr. Prickles, a porcupine, has good reason to be, well, prickly. The other nocturnal forest animals don't want to be anywhere near him and callously spurn his many friendly overtures. His sharp quills are a bit of a sticking point to be sure, but that doesn't mean that Mr. Prickles isn't "cute...cuddly...[and] playful...on the inside." Sadly, the more Chipmunk, Raccoon, and Skunk (who you'd think would be more accepting of unpleasant qualities in others) shun Mr. Prickles, the more bitter and unfriendly he becomes. LaReau's well-paced, pointedly pun-filled text shines a sympathetic light on her lonely protagonist, and the playful (and cute and cuddly) illustrations bring out the best in the spiky hero. Magoon's use of color and varying perspectives in the nighttime scenes effectively convey mood and intensify the story's emotions. Mr. Prickles seems destined to spend his nights alone angrily glaring at the other animals, but fate has other plans when Miss Pointypants, a female porcupine, moves in to the stump next door. The implied message to stick with your own kind is unfortunate, but Mr. Prickles's concluding observation takes some of the sting out: "it's much nicer being alone with someone else." Point taken. kitty flynn
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!