A Possibility of Whales

Gr 5–8—Twelve-year-old Natalia Rose Baleine Gallagher's father, famous movie star Xan Gallagher, tells her, "We all contain multitudes… Everyone isn't ever all one thing." The same could be said of A Possibility of Whales, a remarkable novel that encompasses more than the usual flotsam and jetsam of turning 13. Nat not only experiences her first period and secret crushes, but also aggressive paparazzi, tabloid secrets, a secret stolen cell phone, miraculous whale sightings, and the painful process of losing one best friend and finding another. At the heart of the novel lies the complex and sensitively drawn friendship between Nat and Harry, a transgender boy, as they both struggle to navigate middle school and the expectations of their families. Nat's witty and vulnerable voice drives the novel, from her wry observations about contemporary celebrity culture to the thoughtful collection of untranslatable words that help define her world. The chapters that center Harry's perspective are just as strong, emphasizing his desire to be seen and understood, not as an abstract exemplar of a transgender child but as an individual. The novel avoids offering simple solutions for questions of identity and adolescence, instead reveling in life's nuance and complexity.